Agriculture
From farm to table: How ButtaNutt is reshaping South Africa’s food landscape
Robin Fredericks 29 Jul 2025
Product Recall: ButtaNutt recalls limited peanut butter over toxin fears
ButtaNutt has announced a precautionary food safety recall of limited batches of its peanut butter products after routine internal testing identified slightly elevated aflatoxin levels above the regulatory limit of 10 parts per billion (ppb).
Source: www.buttanutt.co.za
The company confirmed that initial testing detected aflatoxin levels of 46 ppb in the highest affected batch, with a subsequent re-test recording 28 ppb. While these levels exceed regulatory thresholds, ButtaNutt emphasises that it is acting out of an abundance of caution to protect consumers and ensure full regulatory compliance.
Understanding the health risk
ButtaNutt has provided clarity on the potential health implications for consumers who may already have consumed the affected products.
Health experts differentiate between acute (short-term or once-off) exposure and chronic (long-term) exposure. The primary health risks associated with aflatoxins, including liver-related concerns, are typically linked to regular consumption over extended periods of time.
According to scientific guidelines, an adult would generally need to consume more than 2.4kg of peanut butter contaminated at levels as high as 500 ppb, at least three times a week, to potentially experience acute toxic effects.
As such, consumption of a standard serving from the affected batches would be considered a once-off exposure and is highly unlikely to cause immediate or severe health effects.
Affected products and batch codes
The majority of the affected stock has already been secured and removed from the market. However, 83 individual units may still be in consumers’ possession. Consumers are requested to check their cupboards for the following products and batch codes:
- ButtaNutt Chocolate Peanut Butter 250g – Best Before: 15/07/2027
- ButtaNutt 100% Peanut Butter 1kg – Best Before: 17/07/2027
- ButtaNutt 100% Peanut Butter 2.5kg – Best Before: 13/07/2027
- ButtaNutt 100% Peanut Butter 2.5kg – Best Before: 28/07/2027
Stores involved
The affected units were sold at the following retail outlets:
- Jacksons Real Food Market (Kyalami and Bryanston)
- Irene Farm Stall
- Pick n Pay Scottburgh
- Sea Point Spar
- Stellenbosch Superspar (Helshoogte)
- Sonstraal Spar
- Wilderness Spar
The products were also sold via the ButtaNutt online store and the ButtaNutt Factory Shop in Paarl.
What consumers should do
Consumers who have purchased any of the affected products are advised to:
- Not consume or dispose of the product.
- Return the product to the store where it was purchased for a full refund.
- If purchased online via buttanutt.co.za, confirm quantities on hand by email with photos attached, after which collection will be arranged.
Consumers who are unable to return products to the place of purchase or who require further information can contact the ButtaNutt team directly:
Monique – monique@buttanutt.co.za | 072 550 1709
Juanita – juanita@buttanutt.co.za | 066 211 2967
ButtaNutt has apologised for the inconvenience caused and reaffirmed its commitment to the highest standards of food safety, quality assurance and transparency.